Who is better, Chivas or America? An analysis of two of the best teams in Mexico

Who is better, Chivas or America? An analysis of two of the best teams in Mexico

Grace Waruguru
April 6, 2024 at 5:04 PM
In this article:
Club America logo
Club America
Mexico
21
Chivas Guadalajara logo
Chivas Guadalajara
Mexico
22

Who is better, Chivas or America? The debate about the better club has gained attention in Mexico and globally. The two clubs have gained a massive following and achieved incredible success. We compile a detailed analysis of Mexico's two best teams and why fans have divided opinions when picking their favourite.

Chivas and Club America players celebrating
Chivas players (L) celebrate against Pumas UNAM in November 2023. Club America stars (R) celebrate against Jeonbuk Hyundai in December 2016. Photo: Shaun Botterill, Jam Media (modified by author)
Source: Getty Images

Table of Сontents:

Who is more popular, Chivas or America? The two clubs compete in Liga MX, the top professional football division of the Mexican Football League and among the most competitive leagues in North America. They are eternal rivals, each with its history and success.

Who is better, Chivas or America?

Is Club America a good soccer team? America, known fully as Club America, was founded in 1916 and is the most successful Liga MX franchise, with 13 titles. They are based in Mexico City. Chivas Guadalajara was founded in 1906 and headquartered in Jalisco. Both clubs are among the 10 Liga MX founding members.

According to Statista, Club America is owned by Televisa and has a $128.4 million value as of April 2024. The club is also known as Águilas (Eagles), Azul-Cremas (Blue Creams), and Millonetas (Millionaires).

Group Omnilife owns Chivas Guadalajara. The team's nicknames are Chivas Rayadas (Striped Goats), Rebaño Sagrado (Sacred Flock), Rojiblancos (Red and Whites), and Campeonísimo (Great Champion). The team is worth approximately $311 million, as reported by Elfutbolero in 2020.

Who is better, Club America or Chivas?

Is America better than Chivas? Both clubs have gained massive popularity over time. Several factors come into play when deciding the better club, including past performances, the calibre of players, and the number of trophies.

Chivas coach Fernando Gago
Chivas head coach Fernando Gago at the match between Monterrey and Chivas at BBVA Stadium on March 30, 2024, in Monterrey, Mexico. Photo: Alfredo Lopez
Source: Getty Images

The clubs have a long, winding history and have battled it out in over 240 matches as of April 2024. Their rivalry was birthed in February 1944 after America defeated Guadalajara 7-2 during their third match against each other, as reported by Foort247. The game also had the largest score record in the contest.

Chivas vs America players

Club America and Chivas Guadalajara have different recruiting policies. America spends a significant portion of its money on foreign and domestic players.

Chivas have a strict policy of not recruiting foreigners, emphasizing the tradition of maintaining a home-grown culture. Both teams enjoy high ratings and viewership in the US and Mexico.

Who is Club America's biggest rival?
Club America players (L) celebrate against St. Louis City in July 2023. Cristian Calderon of Chivas celebrates against Cruz Azul in April 2022. Photo: Hector Vivas, Bill Barrett (modified by author)
Source: Getty Images

According to One Football, some of Chivas' top players include Omar Bravo, the club's all-time top scorer, Oswaldo Sánchez, and Alberto Coyote. Club America's legendary players include Mario Pérez, Juan Hernández, and Enrique Borja.

Las Chivas vs America head-to-head stats

Which team is better, America or Chivas? Club America has six Copa MX Cups and six Champion of Champions cups. Their rival team has 26 major titles, including seven Champion of Champions and two CONCACAF cups. Here are the teams' head-to-head statistics, as per AiScore.

Tournament

Total

Chivas Guadalajara

Club America

Draws

Estadio Akron

29

10

12

7

Azteca

31

8

13

10

Champions League

2

1

1

0

INT CF

4

0

2

2

Copa MX

3

0

1

2

Liga MX

50

16

21

13

Copa GNP

1

1

0

0

Total matches

60

18

25

17

Total scores

137

60

77

-

Club America attained the record for most victories in a calendar year against Chivas in 2007 when they defeated them on four occasions. The two rivals competed the most times in 2016 (seven).

Club America coach Fernando Ortiz
Club America's head coach Fernando Ortiz during the match against Los Angeles Football Club at SoFi Stadium on August 3, 2022, in Inglewood, California. Photo: Omar Vega
Source: Getty Images

Chivas vs America trophies

Chivas and Club America are the two leading clubs in titles won. Here is a list of international titles won by each team in different local and international championships.

Trophy

Club America

Chivas Guadalajara

CONCACAF

7

2

Interamerican

2

0

CONCACAF Giants Cup

1

0

Mexican Tournament

18

12

Mexican Cup

7

4

Supercopa de Mexico

0

1

Campeón de Campeones

6

7

Frequently Asked Questions

Javier Hernandez of Chivas
Javier Hernandez of Chivas during the match against Leon on March 9, 2024, in Zapopan, Mexico. Photo: Simon Barber
Source: Getty Images

As the raging battle between Chivas and America continues, here are some frequently asked questions about the two football teams.

When was Club America founded?

Club America was founded in 1916 and celebrated its 100th anniversary in 2016. It is based in Mexico City and is among the most popular in Mexico and the USA.

Does Chivas have foreign players?

Chivas Guadalajara has a strict policy of recruiting only Mexican players. The franchise promotes local talent and has also recruited international football players.

Who is Club America's biggest rival?

The Mexican team has a long-standing rivalry with Chivas Guadalajara. Their matches have often brought tension among fans, players, and coaching staff. In 1983, players from both teams exchanged blows during the season's semi-finals, leading to a 20-minute fight and three red cards.

In 1986, the two got into another brawl, forcing the referee to dismiss all 22 players and suspend the match 18 minutes before the final whistle. Club America won the re-scheduled game 1-0. In recent years, the teams' fans and players have accommodated each other better.

Final word

Who is better, Chivas or America? The two teams have played 244 games as of April 2024. Both franchises possess unique strengths that have earned them loyal fans across the globe. Their cut-throat competition will continue entertaining their fans and earning them more popularity.

READ ALSO: Hugo Sanchez biography: The story of the Mexican football legend

Sports Brief published an article featuring Hugo Sanchez's biography. The retired footballer was one of the best strikers in the 80s and spent a significant part of his career with Spanish clubs Atletico Madrid and Real Madrid. What are some exciting facts about his life?

Sanchez was born in July 1958. His father was a professional footballer representing clubs like Atlante and Asturias FC. After a career that lasted two decades, Hugo transitioned to coaching and TV. He has a net worth of $15 million. Check out his detailed biography in the article above.

Authors
Grace Waruguru photo
Grace Waruguru
Grace has over 4 years of experience in article writing and digital media content creation for various local and global brands. She holds a Bachelor's degree in Communication (Public Relations) from Daystar University, Kenya.